10 TOP Honest Reviews Of The best CoverGirl Mascaras for 2019.

When I hear “CoverGirl,” the first thing that comes to mind is mascara(closely followed by RuPaul’s iconic song of the same name). Like many, my very first mascara purchase was a bright orange tube of CoverGirl Lashblast, and I have returned to the classic brand time and time again for big fluttery lashes. Despite a recent rebrand and switch to being 100 percent cruelty-free, CoverGirl has made mascara its bread and butter for its 58 years of existence, and remains one of the biggest contenders in the drugstore aisle. Truly, as more brands are deciding not to launch mascara, CoverGirl continues to churn out new formulas one after another.

Alexa De Paulis

But with so many options, standing in front of its mascara wall at the drugstore is slightly overwhelming. What’s the difference between the Super Sizer and Exhibitionist? And what separates Clump Crusher from Flourish? There’s really only so much deducing you can do while looking at a wand through a piece of plastic. So we enlisted Lamsat-Onotha editors to put every tube to the test and broke down what exactly you get with each option. Read on for our honest reviews of the best CoverGirl mascaras.All products featured on Glamour are independently selected by our editors.


1 of 11